A exterminatory state of mind

For multiple reasons, I’ve always been opposed to people attaching historically-charged terms such as “Nazi” to Israeli policy. However, this little gem published on the very popular Israeli news portal ynet (which also maintains an English version) is so dramatic that it made me question the validity of my traditional arguments.

The item in question is one of those “opinion polls” that ynet — like other sites — publishes on a regular basis. Now, these usually aren’t what you might describe as left-leaning. I’ve often been shocked by the wordings chosen for some of them. This one, however, is an example of a state of mind which can very safely be described as exterminatory. Because of their web-based and random nature, these polls are obviously not representative of the true state of Israeli opinion, and the ynet staff dutifully mentions this in their results. However, the very fact that something like that gets published is no small cause for alarm, especially when it concerns a highly popular news portal which likes to present itself as a serious and unbiased source of information.

In connection with the recent takeover of the Gaza strip by the Islamic militants of Hamas, ynet asks its readers: “What should we do with Gaza?”. Here are the (only) three possible solutions:

1. Go into that nest of vipers for an unlimited time and clean it up.
2. Attack from the air with only a few pinpoint ground strikes.
3. What can we do? As long as they kill each other, everything’s for the best.

I can only assume that some subversive element in ynet is trying to see how far he or she can promote fascist thinking in the mainstream media without getting noticed. Very far indeed, it would seem. If it’s a serious poll — and it very well might be — then it’s also an interesting insight into the Israeli collective consciousness: we either burn everything around us with the help of an oversized military machine, or raise our powerless arms in the air with the hope of seeing the problem disappear by itself. It’s a depressing illustration of what Doron Rosenblum, the ingenious Israeli commentator and writer, once wrote about the Israeli soldiers in the first Palestinian Intifada: on foreign TV it looks like we’re beating teenagers with bludgeons, whereas in reality we’re being led like lambs to the slaughter.

By the way, last time I checked, the third option got 60 percent of the votes.